As you probably know, this week a judge has ruled that a Sikh girl (Sarika Singh) is allowed to wear a Kara (religious bangle) in school after being expelled for refusing to take it off. A link to the full story is here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/7529694.stm
So my intention is to gather some opinions as I personally am absolutely disgusted that such a ruling has been made. I welcome anyone who agrees with me or who has any facts that may make me realise I am in the wrong for thinking such a thing. My argument is as follows:
Firstly and most importantly, this judgement absolutely undermines the whole UK schooling system and the principles that underpin it. The school (Aberdare Girls' School in Wales) has a policy and code of conduct which must be signed by the pupil and parents upon entry to the school, clearly stating:
"Jewellery often poses a health and safety hazard to school
activities. Pupils are allowed to wear a wristwatch and one pair of
plain metal studs in the ear. No other jewellery is permitted."
and the pupil must also sign the school rules:
"I will ensure that my personal appearance is always of the highest possible
standard and is in line with the schools expectations."
I notice the girl is 14, and therefore must have been at the school for at least one full academic year previous to this? And both the parents and pupil signed the code of conduct upon entry to the school? Meaning the parents and pupil agreed to abide by the rules and regulations of the school! So why are they now allowed to take the school to court over something they had willingly agreed to?! It's disgusting. It makes a mockery of the school and diminishes the policies that uphold it.
I hear her lawyer's defence included "...the Kara was as important to her as it was to England spin bowler Monty Panesar". I'm pretty sure Monty Panesar didn't sign a code of conduct to say I will not wear anything other than a watch.
